Geez, Sarah Paulson, tell us how you really feel! All jokes aside, her reason for not loving Roanoke is pretty valid. Marcia Clark in American Crime Story: The People vs. O.J. Simpson was a huge role for Sarah Paulson, earning her an Emmy Award, a SAG Award, and a Golden Globe. If she felt so fulfilled by the novel experience of American Crime Story, it isn’t a stretch to see how she could have felt let down by filming yet another season of AHS.